
Photo by Brian Van Lau, from Rivka Galchen's "Proof of Concept"
This is just a quick comment on two photos in this week’s issue – one I like, the other I’m not so sure about. The one I admire is by Brian Van Lau, from Rivka Galchen’s “Proof of Concept.” It’s a portrait of mathematician Terence Tao. It shows him standing next to a blackboard, chalk in hand, looking directly at the camera. It’s a plain-spoken shot, nothing fancy. That’s what I like about it.
The photo I’m just a little bit skeptical about is by Jessica Haye and Clark Hsiao, from Joshua Yaffa’s “Theatre of War.” It’s a portrait of movie director Andrey Zvyagintsev. He sits in blue-drenched semi-shadow, looking away from the camera. It’s an artful shot. Is it over-stylized? I think so. It’s like a Whistler – “Arrangement in Blue and Gray.”
Both subjects are aware their portraits are being taken. Both are posing. Which pose seems more natural? To me, eyes are telling. Tao looks directly at the camera. Zvyagintsev looks away. The value here is directness. Tao’s portrait has it; Zvyagintsev’s doesn’t.

Photo by Jessica Haye and Clark Hsiao, from Joshua Yaffa's "Theatre of War"
No comments:
Post a Comment