In this one, Franzen travels to the remote island of Masafeura, five hundred miles off the coast of central Chile. He takes two items with him that figure centrally in his narrative. One is a paperback copy of Daniel Defoe’s Robinson Crusoe. The other is a wooden matchbox containing the ashes of his friend David Foster Wallace. Masafuera is devoid of humans, but has millions of birds, including the rare Masafuera rayadito songbird. Franzen hopes to see one while he’s there. Masafuera island, Robinson Crusoe, David Foster Wallace, Masafuera rayadito – those are just some of the ingredients of this strange, exotic, introspective travelogue.
The piece unfolds in six untitled sections. Section one describes Masafuera (“a forbiddingly vertical volcanic island”). It tells what motivated Franzen to go there. He’d been promoting a novel non-stop for four months (“Substantial swaths of my personal history were going dead from within, from my talking about them too often”). He says, “At a certain point, having read about Masafuera, I began to imagine running away and being alone there ... in the interior of the island, where nobody lives even seasonally.” He tells when the idea of scattering Wallace’s ashes on Masafuera first arose:
On the eve of my departure for Santiago, I visited my friend Karen, the widow of the writer David Foster Wallace. As I was getting ready to leave her house, she asked me, out of the blue, whether I might like to take along some of David’s cremation ashes and scatter them on Masafuera. I said I would, and she found an antique wooden matchbox, a tiny book with a sliding drawer, and put some ashes in it, saying that she liked the thought of part of David coming to rest on a remote and uninhabited island.
This section concludes with the image of Franzen at a spot on Masafuera called La Cuchara. He writes,
I had a notebook, binoculars, a paperback copy of “Robinson Crusoe,” the little book containing David’s remains, a backpack filled with camping gear, a grotesquely inadequate map of the island, and no alcohol, tobacco, or computer. Apart from the fact that, instead of hiking up on my own, I’d followed a young park ranger and a mule that was carrying my backpack, and that I’d also brought along, at various people’s insistence, a two-way radio, a ten-year-old G.P.S. unit, a satellite phone, and several spare batteries, I was entirely isolated and alone.
Section two cuts away from the trip. Franzen recalls an experience from his youth, a camping expedition in Idaho, when he had to cope with being left by himself in the wilderness. He says, “What enabled me to stick it out—and to feel, moreover, that I could have stayed alone for longer than a day—was writing.”
Section three shifts back to Masafuera. Franzen describes landing there:
Masafuera, as the boat approached it, was not inviting. My only map of the island was a letter-size printout of a Google Earth image, and I saw right away that I’d optimistically misinterpreted the contour lines on it. What had looked like steep hills were cliffs, and what had looked like gentle slopes were steep hills. A dozen or so lobsterman shacks were huddled at the bottom of a tremendous gorge, to either side of which the island’s green shoulders rose thirty-five hundred feet into a cap of broodingly churning cloud. The ocean, which had seemed reasonably calm on the trip out, was beating in big swells against a gap in the rocks below the shacks. To get ashore, the botanists and I jumped down into a lobster boat, which motored to within a hundred yards of shore. There the boatmen hauled up the motor, and we took hold of a rope stretching out to a buoy and pulled ourselves farther in. As we neared the rocks, the boat lurched chaotically from side to side, water flooding into the stern, while the boatmen struggled to attach us to a cable that would drag us out. Onshore were breathtaking quantities of flies—the place’s nickname is Fly Island. Competing boom boxes pumped North and South American music through the open doors of several shacks, pushing back against the oppressive immensity of the gorge and the coldly heaving sea. Adding to the stricken atmospherics was a grove of large, dead trees, aged to the color of bone, behind the shacks.
A ranger named Danilo leads him to his campsite at La Cuchero. Franzen writes,
Sooner than I’d expected, Danilo and I arrived at La Cuchara and saw, in the fog, the outlines of a small refugio, or ranger’s hut. We’d climbed three thousand feet in just over two hours. I’d heard that there was a refugio at La Cuchara, but I’d imagined a primitive shack and hadn’t foreseen what a problem it would pose for me. Its roof was steep and tethered to the ground by cables, and inside it were a propane stove, two bunk beds with foam mattresses, an unappetizing but serviceable sleeping bag, and a cabinet stocked with dry pasta and canned foods; apparently, I could have brought along nothing but some iodine tablets and still survived here. The refugio’s existence made my already somewhat artificial project of solitary self-sufficiency seem even more artificial, and I resolved to pretend that it didn’t exist.
The ranger departs. Franzen is alone: “Except for the hum of flies and the occasional call of a cinclodes, the silence at my campsite was absolute.” He puts up his tent and makes plans for the next day. He writes,
My plan for the next day was to try to see a rayadito. Simply knowing that the bird was on the island made the island interesting to me. When I go looking for new bird species, I’m searching for a mostly lost authenticity, for the remnants of a world now largely overrun by human beings but still beautifully indifferent to us; to glimpse a rare bird somehow persisting in its life of breeding and feeding is an enduringly transcendent delight. The next morning, I decided, I would get up at dawn and devote, if necessary, the entire day to finding my way to Los Inocentes and getting back. Cheered by the prospect of this not unchallenging quest, I made myself a bowl of chili, and then, although the daylight hadn’t faded yet, I zipped myself inside my tent. On the very comfortable mattress, in a sleeping bag I’d owned since high school, and with a headlamp on my forehead, I settled down to read “Robinson Crusoe.” For the first time all day, I felt happy.
Section four is a commentary on the brilliancies of Robinson Crusoe and the role it played in the rise of the novel. Sample:
We now understand a novel to be a mapping of a writer’s experience onto a waking dream, and a crucial turn toward this understanding can be seen in Defoe’s tentative assertion of a less than strictly historical kind of truth—the novelist’s “truth.”
Section five returns to Franzen’s account of his experience on Masafuera. It’s the climax of the narrative, and its most complex segment. Franzen describes the events of his second day on Masafuera. He tells about his attempt to hike to an area on the island called Los Innocente, where the Masafuera rayadito lives. The weather is bad – “mist turning to rain and blowing horizontally, the wind gusting above forty miles an hour.” He picks his way down a ridge. It begins to narrow alarmingly. He comes to a pinnacle that blocks his way. He can see that the ridge continues to descend on the far side of it. But how to get around it? Franzen describes his dilemma:
In my rain-filled boots, I edged out along the windward side, double-checking every foothold and handhold before relying on it. As I crept forward and was able to see a little farther, the ridge beyond the pinnacle began to look like another dead end, with nothing but dark space ahead and on either side of it. Although I was very determined to see the rayadito, there came a moment when I became afraid to take another step, and I was suddenly able to see myself: spread-eagled against a slippery rockface, in blinding rain and ferocious wind, with no assurance that I was going in the right direction. A sentence so clear that it seemed almost spoken popped into my head: What you’re doing is extremely dangerous. And I thought of my dead friend.
At this point, the narrative shifts. Franzen remembers his friend David Foster Wallace. He writes about his suicide: “He was sick, yes, and in a sense the story of my friendship with him is simply that I loved a person who was mentally ill. The depressed person then killed himself, in a way calculated to inflict maximum pain on those he loved most, and we who loved him were left feeling angry and betrayed.” He writes about Wallace’s work: “Close loving relationships, which for most of us are a foundational source of meaning, have no standing in the Wallace fictional universe.” He traces Wallace’s suicidal impulse to his lack of belief in his own lovability. He says,
He was a lifelong prisoner on the island of himself. What looked like gentle contours from a distance were in fact sheer cliffs. Sometimes only a little of him was crazy, sometimes nearly all of him, but, as an adult, he was never entirely not crazy. What he’d seen of his id while trying to escape his island prison by way of drugs and alcohol, only to find himself even more imprisoned by addiction, seems never to have ceased to be corrosive of his belief in his lovability. Even after he got clean, even decades after his late-adolescent suicide attempt, even after his slow and heroic construction of a life for himself, he felt undeserving. And this feeling was intertwined, ultimately to the point of indistinguishability, with the thought of suicide, which was the one sure way out of his imprisonment; surer than addiction, surer than fiction, and surer, finally, than love.
In the course of his reflection on Wallace’s suicide, Franzen makes a surprising connection between Wallace and Robinson Crusoe. Wallace, he says, had become boring to himself, whereas Crusoe “never, in twenty-eight years on his Island of Despair, becomes bored.” Boredom is one of the themes of this intricate piece. In the first section, Franzen says, “Boredom is what I was suffering from.” Later he refers to his own “desperate boredom.” Of Wallace, he says, “David had died of boredom.” The last word of the piece is “bored” (“As long as we have such complications, how dare we be bored?”).
When Franzen’s meditation on Wallace’s suicide ends, he’s still on the ridge in the wind and rain, grappling with a decision to risk going forward or to turn back. He decides to turn back. He gets back to La Cuchara and dries out his clothes. In the afternoon, he scatters Wallace’s ashes:
It was late afternoon, and the wind was blowing out over the insanely blue ocean, and it was time. La Cuchara seemed more suspended in the air than attached to the earth. There was a feeling of near-infinity, the sun eliciting from the hillsides more shades of green and yellow than I’d suspected the visible spectrum of containing, a dazzling near-infinity of colors, and the sky so immense that I wouldn’t have been surprised to see the mainland on the eastern horizon. White shreds of remnant cloud came barrelling down from the summit, whipped past me, and vanished. The wind was blowing out, and I began to cry, because I knew it was time and I hadn’t prepared myself; had managed to forget. I went to the refugio and got the little box of David’s ashes, the “booklet”—to use the term he’d amusingly applied to his not-short book about mathematical infinity—and walked back down the promontory with it, the wind at my back.
I was doing a lot of different things at every moment. Even as I was crying, I was also scanning the ground for the missing piece of my tent, and taking my camera out of my pocket and trying to capture the celestial beauty of the light and the landscape, and damning myself for doing this when I should have been purely mourning, and telling myself that it was O.K. that I’d failed in my attempt to see the rayadito in what would surely be my only visit to the island—that it was better this way, that it was time to accept finitude and incompleteness and leave certain birds forever unseen, that the ability to accept this was the gift I’d been given and my beloved dead friend had not.
At the end of the promontory, I came to a pair of matching boulders that together formed a kind of altar. David had chosen to leave the people who loved him and give himself to the world of the novel and its readers, and I was ready to wish him well in it. I opened the box of ashes and threw them up into the wind. Some bits of gray bone came down on the slope below me, but the dust was caught in the wind and vanished into the blue vault of the sky, blowing out across the ocean. I turned and wandered back up the hill toward the refugio, where I would have to spend the night, because my tent was disabled. I felt done with anger, merely bereft, and done with islands, too.
Those three wonderful paragraphs are the beating heart of this inspired piece.
Section six concludes the piece. Franzen leaves Masafuera and travels by lobster boat to Masafuera’s sister island, Robinson Crusoe, where he’s stranded for a few days waiting for a flight to the mainland. This section contains a lovely detail: while on Robinson Crusoe, Franzen sees “the Juan Fernández firecrown, a splendid large cinnamon-colored hummingbird.”
“Farther Away” is beautifully conceived and superbly executed – one of the best travel pieces ever to appear in The New Yorker.